Why Sharing Camera Settings Isn’t Enough — Better Questions to Ask

If you’ve spent any time in photography groups online (or at your local camera club), you’ve probably seen it:> Someone posts a photo and the first comment is, “What settings did you use?”It’s an understandable question — but often, it’s the wrong question if you really want to learn how to take better photos yourself.---Why People Ask for Settings? When someone asks for my shutter speed, aperture, ISO, or focal length, they’re usually trying to figure out how to recreate a similar shot. It’s a quick peek behind the curtain: How did you freeze that hummingbird? How did you blur that waterfall?How did you capture the Milky Way without too much noise? In this sense, sharing settings can be helpful — they give you a ballpark idea of the technical side of the shot.

But Here’s the Catch.  Settings alone don’t make the photo. They’re just ingredients. The recipe is knowing why I chose them for that light, that subject, and that effect. 

Aperture, shutter speed, and ISO only work together in the context of: How much light I had, How fast my subject was moving, Whether I was using a tripod or shooting handheld

What artistic look I wanted: tack-sharp or motion-blurred? Wide depth of field or creamy bokeh? 

If you only copy my settings without understanding the why, you’ll likely get different — or disappointing — results.

A Better Way to Learn Instead of just asking, “What were your settings?”, try asking: “Why did you choose that shutter speed? "What was the light like?” "How did you keep the stars sharp at 13 seconds?” “Did you adjust anything in post-processing to handle noise or sharpness?”

Good questions push the conversation deeper. They help you learn how to think like a photographer — not just copy one.--

Here’s a simple template you can use too:

> Settings:

Shutter Speed: ___

Aperture: f/___

ISO: ___

Lens/Focal Length: ___mm

Camera: ___

>Why:

 I used [shutter speed] to [freeze/blur motion].

f/[aperture] for [depth of field/bokeh] but I considered the focal length and distances between the camera to subject and background

ISO [number] to balance exposure and noise in [light conditions].

Try It Yourself Next time you see a shot you admire, ask about the why. 

Next time you share your own, explain your reasoning. Settings are numbers. 

Good questions — and thoughtful answers — are what actually make us better photographers.

Happy shooting